British activist Jo Wilding is in Fallujah, and has sent back an account of her experiences. It deserves a full airing anywhere possible, so here it is in its entirety. Warning: It is extremely disturbing.
April 11th FallujahTrucks, oil tankers, tanks are burning on the highway east to Fallujah. A stream of boys and men goes to and from a lorry that's not burnt, stripping it bare. We turn onto the back roads through Abu Ghraib, Nuha and Ahrar singing in Arabic, past the vehicles full of people and a few possessions, heading the other way, past the improvised refreshment posts along the way where boys throw food through the windows into the bus for us and for the people still inside Fallujah.
The bus is following a car with the nephew of a local sheikh and a guide who has contacts with the Mujahedin and has cleared this with them. The reason I'm on the bus is that a journalist I knew turned up at my door at about 11 at night telling me things were desperate in Fallujah, he'd been bringing out children with their limbs blown off, the US soldiers were going around telling people to leave by dusk or be killed, but then when people fled with whatever they could carry, they were being stopped at the US military checkpoint on the edge of town and not let out, trapped, watching the sun go down.
He said aid vehicles and the media were being turned away. He said there was some medical aid that needed to go in and there was a better chance of it getting there with foreigners, westerners, to get through the American checkpoints. The rest of the way was secured with the armed groups who control the roads we'd travel on. We'd take in the medical supplies, see what else we could do to help and then use the bus to bring out people who needed to leave.
I'll spare you the whole decision making process, all the questions we all asked ourselves and each other, and you can spare me the accusations of madness, but what it came down to was this: if I don't do it, who will? Either way, we arrive in one piece.
We pile the stuff in the corridor and the boxes are torn open straightaway, the blankets most welcomed. It's not a hospital at all but a clinic, a private doctor's surgery treating people free since air strikes destroyed the town's main hospital. Another has been improvised in a car garage. There's no anesthetic. The blood bags are in a drinks fridge and the doctors warm them up under the hot tap in an unhygienic toilet.
Screaming women come in, praying, slapping their chests and faces. "Ummi" (my mother) one cries. I hold her until Maki, a consultant and acting director of the clinic, brings me to the bed where a child of about 10 is lying with a bullet wound to the head. A smaller child is being treated for a similar injury in the next bed. A US sniper hit them and their grandmother as they left their home to flee Fallujah.
The lights go out, the fan stops and in the sudden quiet someone holds up the flame of a cigarette lighter for the doctor to carry on operating by. The electricity to the town has been cut off for days and when the generator runs out of petrol they just have to manage till it comes back on. Dave quickly donates his flashlight. The children are not going to live.
"Come," says Maki and ushers me alone into a room where an old woman has just had an abdominal bullet wound stitched up. Another in her leg is being dressed, the bed under her foot soaked with blood, a white flag still clutched in her hand and the same story: I was leaving my home to go to Baghdad when I was hit by a US sniper. Some of the town is held by US Marines, other parts by the local fighters. Their homes are in the US-controlled area and they are adamant that the snipers were US Marines.
Snipers are causing not just carnage but also the paralysis of the ambulance and evacuation services. The biggest hospital after the main one was bombed is in US territory and cut off from the clinic by snipers. The ambulance has been repaired four times after bullet damage. Bodies are lying in the streets because no one can go to collect them without being shot.
Some said we were mad to come to Iraq; quite a few said we were completely insane to come to Fallujah and now there are people telling me that getting in the back of the pick up to go past the snipers and get sick and injured people is the craziest thing they've ever seen. I know, though, that if we don't, no one will.
The man in the ambulance is holding a white flag with a red crescent on it; I don't know his name. The men we pass wave us on when the driver explains where we're going. The silence is ferocious in the no man's land between the pick up at the edge of the Mujahedin territory, which has just gone from our sight around the last corner and the Marines' line beyond the next wall; no birds, no music, no indication that anyone is still living until a gate opens opposite and a woman comes out, points.
We edge along to the hole in the wall where we can see the car, spent mortar shells around it. The feet are visible, crossed, in the gutter. I think he's dead already. The snipers are visible too, two of them on the corner of the building. As yet I think they can't see us so we need to let them know we're there.
"Hello," I bellow at the top of my voice. "Can you hear me?" They must. They're about 30 metres from us, maybe less, and it's so still you could hear the flies buzzing at 50 paces. I repeat myself a few times, still without reply, so decide to explain myself a bit more.
"We are a medical team. We want to remove this wounded man. Is it OK for us to come out and get him? Can you give us a signal that it's OK?"
I'm sure they can hear me but they're still not responding. Maybe they didn't understand it all, so I say the same again. Dave yells, too, in his American accent. I yell again. Finally I think I hear a shout back. Not sure, I call again.
"Hello."
"Yeah."
"Can we come out and get him?"
"Yeah."
Slowly, our hands up, we go out. The black cloud that rises to greet us carries with it a hot, sour smell. Solidified, his legs are heavy. I leave them to Rana and Dave, our guide lifting under his hips. The Kalashnikov is attached by sticky blood to his hair and hand and we don't want it with us so I put my foot on it as I pick up his shoulders and his blood falls out through the hole in his back. We heave him into the pick up as best we can and try to outrun the flies.
I suppose he was wearing flip flops because he's barefoot now, no more than 20 years old, in imitation Nike pants and a blue and black striped football shirt with a big 28 on the back. As the orderlies form the clinic pull the young fighter off the pick up, yellow fluid pours from his mouth and they flip him over, face up, the way into the clinic clearing in front of them, straight up the ramp into the makeshift morgue.
We wash the blood off our hands and get in the ambulance. There are people trapped in the other hospital who need to go to Baghdad. Siren screaming, lights flashing, we huddle on the floor of the ambulance, passports and ID cards held out the windows. We pack the ambulance with people, one with his chest taped together and a drip, one on a stretcher, legs jerking violently so I have to hold them down as we wheel him out, lifting him over steps.
The hospital is better able to treat these wounded than the clinic, but it hasn't got enough of anything to sort them out properly. The only way to get them to Baghdad is on our bus, which means they have to go to the clinic with us. We're crammed on the floor of the ambulance in case it's shot at. Nisareen, a woman doctor about my age, can't stop a few tears once we're out.
The doctor rushes out to meet me: "Can you go to fetch a lady, she is pregnant and she is delivering the baby too soon?"
Azzam is driving, Ahmed in the middle directing him and me by the window, the visible foreigner, the passport. Something scatters across my hand, simultaneous with the crashing of a bullet through the ambulance, some plastic part dislodged, flying through the window.
We stop, turn off the siren, keep the blue light flashing, wait, eyes on the silhouettes of men in US Marine uniforms on the corners of the buildings. Several shots come. We duck, get as low as possible and I can see tiny red lights whipping past the window, past my head. Some, it's hard to tell, are hitting the ambulance. I start singing. What else do you do when someone's shooting at you? A tire bursts with an enormous noise and a jerk of the vehicle.
I'm outraged. We're trying to get to a woman who's giving birth without any medical attention, without electricity, in a city under siege, in a clearly marked ambulance, and you're shooting at us. How dare you?
How dare you?
Azzam grabs the gear stick and gets the ambulance into reverse, another tire bursting as we go over the ridge in the centre of the road , the shots still coming as we flee around the corner. I carry on singing. The wheels are scraping, burst rubber burning on the road.
The men run for a stretcher as we arrive and I shake my head. They spot the new bullet holes and run to see if we're OK. Is there any other way to get to her, I want to know. "La, maaku tarieq." There is no other way. They say we did the right thing. They say they've fixed the ambulance four times already and they'll fix it again but the radiator's gone and the wheels are buckled and she's still at home in the dark giving birth alone. I let her down.
We can't go out again. For one thing there's no ambulance, and besides, it's dark now and that means our foreign faces can't protect the people who go out with us or the people we pick up. Maki is the acting director of the place. He says he hated Saddam, but now he hates the Americans more.
We take off the blue gowns as the sky starts exploding somewhere beyond the building opposite. Minutes later a car roars up to the clinic. I can hear him screaming before I can see that there's no skin left on his body. He's burnt from head to foot. For sure there's nothing they can do. He'll die of dehydration within a few days.
Another man is pulled from the car onto a stretcher. Cluster bombs, they say, although it's not clear whether they mean one or both of them. We set off walking to Mr. Yasser's house, waiting at each corner for someone to check the street before we cross. A ball of fire falls from a plane, splits into smaller balls of bright white lights. I think they're cluster bombs, because cluster bombs are in the front of my mind, but they vanish, just magnesium flares, incredibly bright but short-lived, giving a flash picture of the town from above.
Yasser asks us all to introduce ourselves. I tell him I'm training to be a lawyer. One of the other men asks whether I know about international law. They want to know about the law on war crimes, what a war crime is. I tell them I know some of the Geneva Conventions, that I'll bring some information next time I come and we can get someone to explain it in Arabic.
We bring up the matter of Nayoko, a Japanese volunteer. This group of fighters has nothing to do with the ones who are holding the Japanese hostages, but while they're thanking us for what we did this evening, we talk about the things Nayoko did for the street kids, how much they loved her. They can't promise anything but that they'll try and find out where she is and try to persuade the group to let her and the others go. I don't suppose it will make any difference. They're busy fighting a war in Fallujah. They're unconnected with the other group. But it can't hurt to try.
The planes are above us all night so that as I doze I forget I'm not on a long distance flight, the constant bass note of an unmanned reconnaissance drone overlaid with the frantic thrash of jets and the dull beat of helicopters and interrupted by the explosions.
In the morning I make balloon dogs, giraffes and elephants for the little one, Abdullah Aboudi, who's clearly distressed by the noise of the aircraft and explosions. I blow bubbles which he follows with his eyes. Finally, finally, I score a smile. The twins, 13 years old, laugh too; one of them is an ambulance driver, both said to be handy with a Kalashnikov.
The doctors look haggard in the morning. None has slept more than a couple of hours a night for a week. One as had only eight hours of sleep in the last seven days, missing the funerals of his brother and aunt because he was needed at the hospital.
"The dead we cannot help," Jassim said. "I must worry about the injured."
We go again, Dave, Rana and me, this time in a pick up. There are some sick people close to the Marines' line who need evacuating. No one dares come out of their house because the Marines are on top of the buildings shooting at anything that moves. Saad fetches us a white flag and tells us not to worry, he's checked and secured the road, no Mujahedin will fire at us, that peace is upon us. He is an 11 year old child, his face covered with a keffiyeh but for is bright brown eyes, his AK-47 almost as tall as he is.
We shout again to the soldiers, hold up the flag with a red crescent sprayed onto it. Two come down from the building, cover this side and Rana mutters, "Allahu akbar. Please nobody take a shot at them."
We jump down and tell them we need to get some sick people from the houses and they want Rana to go and bring out the family from the house whose roof they're on. Thirteen women and children are still inside, in one room, without food and water for the last 24 hours.
"We're going to be going through soon clearing the houses," the senior one says.
"What does that mean, clearing the houses?"
"Going into every one searching for weapons." He's checking his watch, can't tell me what will start when, of course, but there's going to be air strikes in support. "If you're going to do this you gotta do it soon."
First we go down the street we were sent to. There's a man, face down, in a white dishdasha, a small round red stain on his back. We run to him. Again the flies have got there first. Dave is at his shoulders, I'm by his knees and as we reach to roll him onto the stretcher Dave's hand goes through his chest, through the cavity left by the bullet that entered so neatly through his back and blew his heart out.
There's no weapon in his hand. Only when we arrive, his sons come out, crying, shouting. He was unarmed, they scream. He was unarmed. He just went out the gate and they shot him. None of them have dared come out since. No one had dared come to get his body, horrified, terrified, forced to violate the traditions of treating the body immediately. The family couldn't have known we were coming, so it's inconceivable that anyone came out and retrieved a weapon but left the body.
He was unarmed, 55 years old, shot in the back.
We cover his face, carry him to the pick up. There's nothing to cover his body with. The sick woman is helped out of the house, the little girls around her hugging cloth bags to their bodies, whispering, "Baba. Baba." Daddy. Daddy. Shaking, they let us go first, hands up, around the corner, then we usher them to the cab of the pick up, shielding their heads so they can't see him, the cuddly fat man stiff in the back.
The people seem to pour out of the houses now in the hope we can escort them safely out of the line of fire, kids, women, men, anxiously asking us whether they can all go, or only the women and children. We go to ask. The young Marine tells us that men of fighting age can't leave. What's fighting age, I want to know. He contemplates. Anything under forty five. No lower limit.
It appalls me that all those men would be trapped in a city which is about to be destroyed. Not all of them are fighters, not all are armed. It's going to happen out of the view of the world, out of sight of the media, because most of the media in Fallujah is embedded with the Marines or turned away at the outskirts. Before we can pass the message on, two explosions scatter the crowd in the side street back into their houses.
Rana's with the Marines evacuating the family from the house they're occupying. The pick up isn't back yet. The families are hiding behind their walls. We wait, because there's nothing else we can do. We wait in no man's land. The Marines, at least, are watching us through binoculars; maybe the local fighters are too.
I've got a disappearing hanky in my pocket so while I'm sitting like a lemon, nowhere to go, gunfire and explosions aplenty all around, I make the hanky disappear, reappear, disappear. It's always best, I think, to seem completely unthreatening and completely unconcerned, so no one worries about you enough to shoot. We can't wait too long though. Rana's been gone for ages. We have to go and get her to hurry. There's a young man in the group. She's talked them into letting him leave too.
A man wants to use his police car to carry some of the people, a couple of elderly ones who can't walk far, the smallest children. It's missing a door. Who knows if he was really a police car or the car was reappropriated and just ended up there? It didn't matter if it got more people out faster. They creep from their houses, huddle by the wall, follow us out, their hands up too, and walk up the street clutching babies, bags, each other.
The pick up gets back and we shovel as many onto it as we can as an ambulance arrives from somewhere. A young man waves from the doorway of what's left of a house, his upper body bare, a blood soaked bandage around his arm, probably a fighter but it makes no difference once someone is wounded and unarmed. Getting the dead isn't essential. Like the doctor said, the dead don't need help, but if it's easy enough then we will. Since we're already OK with the soldiers and the ambulance is here, we run down to fetch them in. It's important in Islam to bury the body straightaway.
The ambulance follows us down. The soldiers start shouting in English for it to stop, pointing guns. It's moving fast. We're all yelling, signaling for it to stop but it seems to take forever for the driver to hear and see us. It stops. It stops, before they open fire. We haul them onto the stretchers and run, shove them in the back. Rana squeezes in the front with the wounded man and Dave and I crouch in the back beside the bodies. He says he had allergies as a kid and hasn't got much sense of smell. I wish, retrospectively, for childhood allergies, and stick my head out the window.
The bus is going to leave, taking the injured people back to Baghdad, the man with the burns, one of the women who was shot in the jaw and shoulder by a sniper, several others. Rana says she's staying to help. Dave and I don't hesitate: we're staying too.
"If I don't do it, who will?" has become an accidental motto and I'm acutely aware after the last foray how many people, how many women and children, are still in their houses either because they've got nowhere to go, because they're scared to go out of the door or because they've chosen to stay.
To begin with it's agreed, then Azzam says we have to go. He hasn't got contacts with every armed group, only with some. There are different issues to square with each one. We need to get these people back to Baghdad as quickly as we can. If we're kidnapped or killed it will cause even more problems, so it's better that we just get on the bus and leave and come back with him as soon as possible.
It hurts to climb onto the bus when the doctor has just asked us to go and evacuate some more people. I hate the fact that a qualified medic can't travel in the ambulance but I can, just because I look like the sniper's sister or one of his mates, but that's the way it is today and the way it was yesterday and I feel like a traitor for leaving, but I can't see where I've got a choice. It's a war now and as alien as it is to me to do what I'm told, for once I've got to.
Jassim is scared. He harangues Mohammed constantly, tries to pull him out of the driver's seat while we're moving. The woman with the gunshot wound is on the back seat, the man with the burns in front of her, being fanned with cardboard from the empty boxes, his intravenous drips swinging from the rail along the ceiling of the bus. It's hot. It must be unbearable for him.
Saad comes onto the bus to wish us well for the journey. He shakes Dave's hand and then mine. I hold his in both of mine and tell him "Dir balak," take care, as if I could say anything more stupid to a preteen Mujahedin with an AK-47 in his other hand, and our eyes meet and stay fixed, his full of fire and fear.
Can't I take him away? Can't I take him somewhere he can be a child? Can't I make him a balloon giraffe and give him some drawing pens and tell him not to forget to brush his teeth? Can't I find the person who put the rifle in the hands of that little boy? Can't I tell someone about what that does to a child? Do I have to leave him here where there are heavily armed men all around him and lots of them are not on his side, however many sides there are in all of this? And of course I do. I do have to leave him, like child soldiers everywhere.
The way back is tense, the bus almost getting stuck in a dip in the sand, people escaping in anything, even piled on the trailer of a tractor, lines of cars and pick ups and buses ferrying people to the dubious sanctuary of Baghdad, lines of men in vehicles queuing to get back into the city having got their families to safety, either to fight or to help evacuate more people. The driver, Jassim, the father, ignores Azzam and takes a different road so that suddenly we're not following the lead car and we're on a road that's controlled by a different armed group than the ones which know us.
A crowd of men waves guns to stop the bus. Somehow they apparently believe that there are American soldiers on the bus, as if they wouldn't be in tanks or helicopters, and there are men getting out of their cars with shouts of "Sahafa Amreeki," American journalists. The passengers shout out of the windows, "Ana min Fallujah," I am from Fallujah. Gunmen run onto the bus and see that it's true, there are sick and injured and old people, Iraqis, and then relax, wave us on.
We stop in Abu Ghraib and swap seats, foreigners in the front, Iraqis less visible, headscarves off so we look more western. The American soldiers are so happy to see westerners they don't mind too much about the Iraqis with us, search the men and the bus, leave the women unsearched because there are no women soldiers to search us. Mohammed keeps asking me if things are going to be OK.
"Al-melaach wiyana, " I tell him. The angels are with us. He laughs.
And then we're in Baghdad, delivering them to the hospitals, Nuha in tears as they take the burnt man off groaning and whimpering. She puts her arms around me and asks me to be her friend. I make her feel less isolated, she says, less alone.
And the satellite news says the cease-fire is holding and George Bush says to the troops on Easter Sunday that, "I know what we're doing in Iraq is right." Shooting unarmed men in the back outside their family home is right? Shooting grandmothers with white flags is right? Shooting at women and children who are fleeing their homes is right? Firing at ambulances is right?
Well George, I know too now. I know what it looks like when you brutalize people so much that they've nothing left to lose. I know what it looks like when an operation is being done without anesthetic because the hospitals are destroyed or under sniper fire and the city's under siege and aid isn't getting in properly. I know what it sounds like too. I know what it looks like when tracer bullets are passing your head, even though you're in an ambulance. I know what it looks like when a man's chest is no longer inside him and what it smells like and I know what it looks like when his wife and children pour out of his house.
It's a crime and it's a disgrace to us all.
Interestingly I happened upon this article right after watching the president give his press conference this evening. It is amazing how he can make this war sound so positive while American soldjers are killing hundreds of innocent people, who by the way did not ask them to be there in the first place. I hope that alot of people read this account of the war on terrorism before the election in November. Thanks for doing all that you can to get the word out there. I guess that should be said to Jo as well as you Brooke. Namaste
Posted by: Jolene | Tuesday, April 13, 2004 at 07:09 PM
Thank you for posting this. It made me sick to my stomach. I feel an intense hatred for each marine combatant and officer complicit in these war crimes.
I used to be proud I was American.
Posted by: david | Thursday, April 15, 2004 at 05:22 PM
It makes me sick to read apologist propoganda like this.
I wonder how many fighters she saw shoting at American soldiers?
Were these fighters in uniform, or did they look just
like every other person in the street? Did fighters use
ambulances to deceive the Americans? Perhaps to get closer
so they can be more deadly?
Ask yourself which person in Iraq have threatened to "burn alive"
innoceet civilian hostages. It was the so called "fighters".
Posted by: Pinky | Thursday, April 15, 2004 at 09:24 PM
pinky, you dumb SOB, you can't even spell "propaganda," or even "shooting."
Posted by: sagesource | Friday, April 16, 2004 at 12:14 AM
Sad, although questionable story. Reportage? Not sure, although obviously LOADED with bias, as much as I agree.
Emm...no question, in hindsight...monstrous bias. The narrative is fascinating; the editorializing is awful.
Shit(e) journalism.
This MARS your site.
Posted by: Matthew | Friday, April 16, 2004 at 01:25 AM
I feel an intense hatred for each marine combatant and officer complicit in these war crimes.
Emmm..to interrupt again..."an intense hatred for each marine combatant"...???
President Bush, Commander-in-Chief has the authority, and utilized it, to order military personnel to do as he pleases. Military combatants are under his orders. He is their boss. There is NO recourse to HIS orders.
President Bush ordered his troops to kill "evil-doers"...that, apparently, meant 3 year old children with darker skin than his.
President Bush also told the world, repeatedly, that the if you were not with "us" you were "with" the terrorists...
One could then imagine that "the evil-doers" "the terrorists" the "stem-cell scientists" were working hard to undermine the USA's resolve by planting terror cells to provide the option for gay marriage.
How many men and women were killed tonight? How many of them were gay?
Posted by: Matthew | Friday, April 16, 2004 at 01:46 AM
It pisses me off to hear someone talk about how much they hate the Marines now because of this article. Cut us all some fucking slack, please.
First of all, it's not the Marines' fault that we have an imperialist moron asshole for a president who's basically a sock puppet with Dick Cheney's hand up his ass. Naive or not, most people don't join the military with visions of world domination dancing in their heads.
Second of all, if you can't see the slant in this piece then you clearly need a flashlight. Although it DOES point out some very important things about war that the Pentagon and the media would rather we forget (such as the fact that innocent people die in droves, and that yes, Virginia, getting shot hurts like a motherfucker), it also very obviously fails to note that at least some of the folks shooting at the US troops are not simple farmers protecting their carrot harvest from invading foreigners, but are THEMSELVES invading foreigners who couldn't give two shits about how many civilians they kill. The article also fails to probe the criminality of conscripting children, nor does it put into context why US soldiers might shoot at an ambulance. The suggestion is that US soldiers just sort of like taking potshots at civilians, which is frankly stupid when you consider that some of these combatants are not above using civilian vehicles as weapons, and otherwise violating the Geneva Convention in a variety of imaginative ways.
Refusing to try to comprehend the complexity of this situation makes you no better a critical thinker than our president. And you see where that's gotten us.
Posted by: Carpenter | Friday, April 16, 2004 at 08:33 AM
Whether this article is biased or not-to quote an infamous quote "War Is Hell". I hate war and I hate that we are involved with the realities of today-terrorism. Let's take a moment and put some perspective in our lives....be greatful that we have running water, grocery stores, and hospitals.
I do not support what is going on but I do not wish for us to be so nasty to each other. This was a thought provoking article but let's not provoke each other.
My thoughts are that we need to get out and get out soon because I do this war as another Vietnam. We are trying to make another country bend to our will and thoughts. It doesn't work and it won't work. I really, really wish that more talk and less military action would work.
I could go on and on but I think I spoke what I really needed to say.
One last thought-I've watched specials that interviewed men who fought in WWII. Some cried shamelessly....
Posted by: Abeth | Friday, April 16, 2004 at 10:01 AM
I agree that it isn't just Marines being evil (Jo Wilding was later kidnapped by enemy combatants, who if you read the article, she was JUST as scared of) - Wilding was helping civilians wounded in WAR, not just by Americans. However, the war we hqappenb to bge having over there was caused by America, and the blame lies there. Not with the Marines necessarily or primarily, but with Bush et al.
Last night I talked to my friend Matias, who is shipping out for Iraq in a week. He's an infantry scout (read: dead meat). I told him not to get killed, but also to be careful because i knew it was impossible to tell civilians from combatants sometimes. He says to me, "I'm inclined to shoot first and ask questions later." Then he paused and said, "Actually, I just want to be honorable." That's a hell of a hard balance, and the first response is the one that will come to him with his finger on the trigger.
Posted by: brooke | Friday, April 16, 2004 at 02:36 PM
Unless you have served in an infantry unit...served in a forward area...put you life in another man's hands and asked him to put his life in yours.................
Don't judge! This is a far cry from intentionally targeting civilians! Like Osama for instance. If the American Military was intentionally targeting civilians as Osama or Saddam has, do you really think there would be many Iraqi's left at this point?
If a Marine has killed innocents.....it was by mistake! Tell the terrorists who are striking at the Marines to "Be Men" and put on a uniform distinctive from the native dress! That would be a helpful. Second, stop running into the cities for cover where you can easily "blend in" with the woman and children! Also, don't run into your mosques just to fire back at marines.....doing is only a feeble attempt at taking our kindness for granted!
Who here believes they are safe in their church or synagogue (without firing) from the likes of Osama?
They surrounded the city out of concern.....if they had no concern whatsoever (osama, saddam, etc.) for civilians......they would have just carpet bombed the entire city......period! Remember Hitler anyone. Your criticisms are unfounded as are your brains!
Posted by: Bart | Sunday, April 18, 2004 at 02:57 AM
Thankyou, Jo!
You are doing a very important work!
I/we wish you and your fellow-journalists all the best!
Greetings from Denmark,
Flemming Schreiber Pedersen,
Hårbyvej 15, Hårby,
8660-Skanderborg
Posted by: Flemming Schreiber Pedersen | Monday, April 19, 2004 at 10:50 PM
While Jo's personal account is moving, like others have commented it is incredibly biased. A professional journalist would have kept this one in the personal journal and stuck to the facts. The only thing that should be taken at face value from her personal account is that the Iraq war is a bloody, disorganized mess- and who didn't really know that already? and since when is guerilla warfare conducive to strict adherance to the Geneva Convention? I think this was an excellent response to the post, far more detailed than I care to be, I found it on opendemocracy.com : http://www.opendemocracy.com/forums/thread.jspa?forumID=77&threadID=42521&tstart=0
Posted by: Leo | Tuesday, April 20, 2004 at 12:30 AM
Touching account, but theres no proof that U.S Marines killed or wounded each and everyone of those people. Sure some civilianshave been killed, but how many had saddam murdered in the past? How can anyone say they hate the Marines? They're doing what has been asked of them. If you were in a city being shot at by a 12 year old with a gun wouldnt you shoot back? Be proud of the men and women who give their lives to us.
I used to be proud I was American.
Posted by: david | April 15, 2004 05:22 PM
And this guy you can get the hell out of America.
I STILL AM PROUD!!!!
Posted by: Jay | Wednesday, April 21, 2004 at 11:01 PM
You know what makes me less proud to be an American? People who say things like "You can get the hell out of America."
Posted by: Carpenter | Thursday, April 22, 2004 at 09:12 AM
No matter what they might like you to believe, one does not abdicate their personal responsibilities upon becoming a Marine.
Posted by: | Friday, April 23, 2004 at 07:45 AM
The article was incredibly biased, but what else would you expect of an "activist"? That's her function. She hopefully does not claim to be unbiased. The idea of women and children being shot (barring the ones stupid enough to bear arms against the US) by Marine snipers is just plain ludicrous. A Marine sniper is a disciplined soldier, shooting one shot at a specific target, and, likely enough, hitting that target. They do not shoot at children and non-combatant women.
They do not indiscriminately spray ammunition at random.
If you wish to hate someone, start at the top and work down--don't start with the poor bastards charged with implementing policies that you may disagree with.
Posted by: bigTom | Sunday, April 25, 2004 at 03:38 PM
Might I say, that although yes, there is a bias in this article, there's still a truth that we as Americans need to hear. This war is wrong - most people knew it was wrong before it started. Is it a surprise that no one can possibly win now? If America backs down, Iraq suffers through lack of organization. If America doesn't back down, more monstrosities like this will keep happening and the Iraqi people will continue to suffer horrendously. Catch-22. My personal comment would be that we should remove the source of the problem- we removed the dictator from Iraq, now let's do the same thing here at home. If we impeached Clinton for lying about screwing one person, why don't we impeach Bush for lying and screwing millions of people in several countries?
Posted by: K | Sunday, April 25, 2004 at 06:40 PM
I am truely sorry that innocent people were injured and killed, but did you really expect war to be all sunshine and daisies? The Marines are fighting an invisible enemy and are doing the best they can. So on that note I applaude them. And in case you are wandering, I do support the war in Iraq and President Bush. So will all the bias people just step off, Please?!
Posted by: a citizen of the U.S.A and proud of it! | Saturday, May 01, 2004 at 08:49 PM
Sadly, comments on this site go to show that some people are willing to accuse Jo of bias just because she has narrated the events as she saw it. Fear and anguish from the Iraqi's point of view is taken as a threat by people whose sadistic, criminal and murderous thinking is apparent by comments like “they would have just carpet bombed the entire city......period”
PATHETIC! Especially in view of the fact that the Military DOES carpet bomb cities at different time intervals- whereas the complaints coming from US soldiers stationed around Fallujah amount to “Its nice to be back in my bed, after sleeping in the dirt so long”… or quoting the combatant who “wanted to stay and fight”, because his buddy was killed fighting the militia. He failed to mention that 3000+ Iraqi civilians were killed in the month of April, whereas 110 American soldiers were killed.
The critics here want people to believe that the US marines with their state of the art “TARGETED” equipment killed 3000+ by MISTAKE??
And lets come out of this rut, where we give the contrived excuse of Osama for justifying mass murder. It is not just lame it is also highly un-intelligent! Osama gave the same excuse as Bush is giving right now, and trying to justify it belies a person’s bias against other humans.
Lets see these purported Moralists and patriots go to Iraq and then help a burning man or an expectant mother deliver her own baby!!! Let just see them even go to Iraq to help the marines tired of sleeping in the dirt!
That will never happen---people like these are only willing to go and join the military and shoot any person that doesn’t look like them – and then claim they were disguised as civilians!
Posted by: Tamseela | Wednesday, May 05, 2004 at 01:25 AM
What a piece of shitty lies. Fuck you.
Posted by: e | Thursday, May 13, 2004 at 12:35 AM
I would just like to point out that Jo Wilding has a website- google it if you want to find it. I know that the truth hurts, and I applaud any American who can stand back from the misinformation being spread by your government (and mine- I'm British), and make an objective decision divorced from patriotism.
Patriotism is like being in love: ultimately it's irrational. However, love affairs rarely kill innocent people. Unless those people who are clearly hard of thinking can start to sit up and take some kind of responsibility for this, your country is going to be torn apart, I'm afraid. It is a beautiful country with many good people in it. Unfortunately, your government and certain attitudes are making it seem like the bully of the world.
Posted by: e | Thursday, May 20, 2004 at 07:09 PM
The other thing I wanted to say is that I am not the same 'e' as the who left that charming comment just before me.
Posted by: e | Thursday, May 20, 2004 at 07:11 PM
Sadly, if I was a marine in Fallujah being shot at I would probably shoot at what ever moved too. As far as this article, it states it's written by an activist. best taken with a grain of salt. To all anti american leftist shit's just fucking move to Iraq and join Al sadr, so an accurate shooting marine can put a bullet in your head!
Posted by: | Tuesday, June 15, 2004 at 06:53 PM
I couldn't read most of the hate statements - However, marines do what marines are trained to do - and most were kids who couldn't get a job. From my perspective the blame sits right on the shoulders of Bush, Blair and Howard - and remember the majority of people in UK and Australia were, and still are, utterly opposed to their young men being sent to kill and die so that Bush's rich mates can get even richer.
John
Posted by: john | Friday, December 10, 2004 at 01:18 AM
It's easy to hate war.
Childish thinking turns that hatred toward soldiers who are forced to kill people that are either trying to kill them first, or who are in SUPPORT of those who are. To direct hatred and disgust at those men who are dealing with the unbelievable stress and horror of house-to-house combat for the purpose of overcoming the greatest threat to the civilized world in the last 300 years is shameful and best...and treasonous on it's face.
What these compassionate idiots who are opposing those who are protecting them and the civilized environment that enables their sophomoric clamoring fail to comprehend, is that these supposed "innocent" people who are getting killed in a COMBAT ZONE wouldn't be IN a combat zone if they were truly innocent!!! In fact, they SHOULD be fighting the insurgents along side us, as they are in other areas, in the name of bringing their violent culture of death and oppression into the 21st Century with the rest of civilization. Innocent, indeed! Our U.N.-dominated, new world order national soveriegnty hating media/elites do everything they can to hide the images of these supposedly "innocent" women and children dancing in the street at the news of something as cowardly and cold-blooded as 9/11...for the purpose of leading simple-minded liberals to believe they are truly innocent, when they would carve out your eyes with a spoon or blow themselves up to kill you if you gave them half a chance due to their demonic hatred of Israel's right to exist, and our support of that simple concept.
Ignorance is deadly in this conflict, folks.
Posted by: Chuck | Saturday, December 18, 2004 at 01:01 PM